DEEP LOOK | Given the potential impact of uneven regulation and the cost of intraday credit in a T+1 environment, PostTrade 360° looks at whether financial institutions have made meaningful progress towards measuring and managing intraday liquidity in real-time.
T+1 makes intraday liquidity management a question not just of cash but also of whether securities and collateral are available when needed. A delayed recall or late securities receipt can transmit pressure through the settlement chain, even where participants have sufficient funding overall.
Harmonised market practices can reduce much of that avoidable pressure, suggests Giovanni Sabatini, chair of the EU T+1 Industry Committee. “Earlier instructions and sale notifications, standardised recall messaging and greater use of partial settlement can all help,” he says. “Early settlement should also be encouraged where it releases cash or securities needed elsewhere.”
The harder risks to resolve through market practice alone are structural constraints on access to liquidity or the ability to mobilise collateral. Coordination between participants can improve the timing of flows but it cannot necessarily remove the underlying constraints.
Gating (controlling when particular settlement instructions are released) therefore needs careful application, adds Sabatini. “It can help synchronise settlement legs and support optimisation, including technical netting, but it should not become a blanket setting or a new de facto settlement deadline,” he continues. “One participant’s funding decision should not unexpectedly disrupt another’s settlement obligations.”
Pushed down the priority list
There has been much debate over whether the industry is genuinely improving liquidity visibility or mainly investing in technology to meet tighter deadlines.
The impact of T+1 on cash management and FX generally means more cost, especially for buy-side firms that are not using real-time processes. Liquidity and cash management may be suboptimal post-implementation but it won’t have as dramatic an impact as failing to support same day allocation processes, for example, so it tends to be pushed down the priority list.
That is the view of Virginie O’Shea, founder of Firebrand Research, who adds that the focus of most projects has been on the most immediate deadlines and priorities. “Though some firms have reviewed liquidity impacts and looked at FX process changes that may be needed as part of their preparations, this is not the norm across the whole industry,” she says. “Some firms still haven’t done this work for US T+1 and we are several years after the fact.”
Same-day FX as a backstop
A shorter securities settlement cycle means funding must be available sooner but this does not necessarily mean investors will turn to same-day FX to source that liquidity since banks have other sources of intraday liquidity.
However, Lisa Danino-Lewis, chief growth officer at CLS accepts that T+1 does leave less time for expected cash flows to arrive or alternative funding to be arranged. “Where the required currency is unavailable, same-day FX can cover the shortfall,” she says. “For investors, the time available to arrange funding also depends on custodian cut-off times. Earlier cut-offs leave investment managers less time to arrange the FX and funding needed to meet T+1 obligations.”
Operating model first, platform second
The good news for market participants is that there is no shortage of technology solutions or vendor support with mature solutions available for liquidity forecasting, intraday monitoring, stress testing, collateral management and funding optimisation.
The challenge lies in implementing these solutions effectively and making sure they are fed timely, accurate information, suggests Roy Zimmerhansl, head of capital markets at WTS Hansuke. “One of the most common mistakes we see is firms selecting technology before they have properly defined their target operating model,” he says. “They choose a platform and only discover during implementation that certain workflows, integration requirements or reporting needs were not properly understood at the outset.”
Zimmerhansl observes that requirements should drive technology selection – not the other way around – and that even the most sophisticated real-time platform cannot compensate for incomplete data, delayed messaging or an operational inability to mobilise collateral. “It is also worth separating product availability from implementation capacity,” he adds. “The technology may exist but firms still need internal resources, vendor support, testing environments and enough time to deliver complex change. Inevitably, as we get closer to T+1 go-live, there will be a squeeze on resources.”
Early warning, not another dashboard
What matters is not simply having another dashboard showing what has happened. The real value is having actionable information early enough to respond, suggests Thomas Hansen, global head of securities finance at Santander.
“If cash, collateral or securities are likely to be unavailable at a particular point in the day, firms need to identify that early enough to source funding, mobilise collateral or resolve the underlying settlement issue,” he says. “The published European implementation guidance similarly identifies automation, improved data quality and greater standardisation as key elements of T+1 readiness.”
Protecting the netting dividend
It is also worth noting that a large part of the solution for many firms may be less about technology and more about simplification of booking models, internal flows and even legal entity structures according to Rollo Burgess, partner & UK post-trade capital markets lead at Capco, who refers to netting as a prerequisite for modern financial markets.
“This is a major reason why talk of a possible future move to a T+0 settlement convention opens a very complex set of questions,” he adds. “It is not at all clear to me that this will ever be a good idea, though I do note that the ability to settle certain selected transactions on T+0 is needed for a T+1 world.”
Val Wotton, managing director and global head of equities solutions at DTCC says there is clear evidence of the benefits of netting in the US but warns against translating that directly into a measure of intraday liquidity efficiency in Europe where the market is more fragmented.
“However, the underlying principle remains the same,” he says. “Efficient netting reduces gross settlement obligations and therefore the amount of funding and collateral that market participants need to mobilise. As markets consider further changes to trading and settlement models, it will be important to preserve those netting efficiencies rather than inadvertently increasing funding or collateral requirements.”
Better coordination or new rules?
Wotton suggests harmonisation alone will not eliminate every liquidity risk, noting that cross-border and FX funding are important considerations because firms may need to mobilise cash in another currency within a much shorter timeframe.
“Market holidays, securities lending recalls and differences between settlement and funding windows can create additional complexity,” he says. “There is therefore a role for both industry and regulators. The industry should continue to drive automation, standardisation, data quality and more efficient operating practices while regulators have an important role where achieving consistency requires changes to market rules, legal certainty or coordinated implementation across jurisdictions.”
Sabatini reckons the immediate priority should be implementing and testing the framework already being developed, rather than making readiness dependent on further regulation. However, he also acknowledges that where that work identifies persistent structural risks that better market practice or infrastructure cannot adequately address, targeted regulatory coordination may be necessary.
“The distinction is between problems that require better coordination and those that require changes to the rules,” he says. “Regulation should address a demonstrated gap.”
Gating: handle with care
One of the most high-profile changes being introduced to support T+1 settlement is the gating event, which Burgess describes as a well-intentioned attempt to improve liquidity by changing settlement conventions for repo transactions.
However, he adds that this change is causing some concern to market participants and carries a risk of unintended consequences. “This may be an area where further regulatory guidance is needed,” he says.
Where harmonisation runs out
Harmonised market practices work very well where the problem is inconsistent behaviour or avoidable operational friction. Areas such as earlier instruction processing, standardised recall messaging, prompt sale notifications and greater use of partial settlements are all examples where industry coordination can deliver meaningful improvement.
The more difficult risks involve dependencies that no individual firm can control, observes Zimmerhansl. These include the timing of counterparties’ payments, access to market liquidity, the availability of credit and the ability to mobilise collateral during periods of stress.
He recommends three layers of response:
- Industry initiatives focusing on reducing avoidable delays and improving predictability
- Market infrastructure providers focusing on operating windows, settlement functionality and transparency
- Regulators and central banks focusing on structural issues such as legal certainty, collateral eligibility, liquidity access and cross-border consistency
“If I had to identify one area most likely to require regulatory coordination, it would be cross-border interoperability,” says Zimmerhansl. “Firms can adapt their own processes but they cannot independently resolve differences in regulatory frameworks, settlement conventions or collateral treatment across jurisdictions. Harmonisation can remove friction but it cannot create liquidity and during periods of market stress, that distinction becomes critically important.”
Where genuine structural barriers remain, regulatory or infrastructure action may ultimately be required, agrees Hansen, although his preference would be to allow the industry solutions currently being developed to be implemented and properly tested before concluding that additional regulation is required.
“T+1 does not create intraday liquidity risk but it makes weaknesses in visibility, sequencing and collateral mobility much less forgiving,” he concludes. “The objective should be to address those weaknesses without introducing measures that unnecessarily restrict liquidity or prevent transactions from settling as early as possible.”










